Cheesy Baked Potato and Mushroom Casserole with Creamy Herb Sauce

This post may contain affiliate links learn more

This Cheesy Baked Potato and Mushroom Casserole with Creamy Herb Sauce is a celebration of comfort food made with simple, wholesome ingredients. Layers of creamy potatoes, hearty mushrooms, caramelized onions, fresh herbs, and gooey cheese come together in a beautifully baked dish that’s both filling and flavorful. With a rich and savory topping sauce made from sour cream, mayonnaise, garlic, and dill, this recipe bridges rustic flavors with a refined finish. It’s perfect for cozy family dinners, vegetarian-friendly meals, or potluck gatherings that need a guaranteed crowd-pleaser.

Preparation Time: 25 minutes
Cook Time: 40 minutes
Total Time: 1 hour 5 minutes
Yield: 6 servings
Cuisine: European-inspired comfort food

A full list of ingredients

For the base mixture:

3 eggs

4 medium potatoes
A handful of fresh parsley, chopped
1 small onion, finely chopped

1 tsp paprika (or to taste)
Salt and black pepper, to taste
Sweet paprika, to taste

2 tablespoons all-purpose flour

For the sautéed vegetable layer:

1 tablespoon butter
1 small onion, sliced
6 mushrooms, sliced

1 medium carrot, grated
2 cloves garlic, minced
Salt and black pepper, to taste

For the creamy topping:

100 ml cream

50 g cheese, shredded
50 g mozzarella cheese, shredded
1 tomato, thinly sliced

For the herb sauce:

3 tablespoons sour cream

1 tablespoon mayonnaise
1–2 cloves garlic, minced
A handful of fresh dill, finely chopped

Salt and black pepper, to taste

Step-by-step cooking directions

Prepare the potato base:
- Preheat the oven to 180°C (350°F).
- Crack 3 eggs into a large mixing bowl.
- Peel and grate the 4 potatoes, rinse under cold water to remove excess starch, then add them to the egg mixture.
- Add chopped parsley, onions, paprika, salt, black pepper, sweet paprika, and flour.
- Mix everything well to create a thick, seasoned potato batter.

Bake the first layer:
- Line a baking dish with parchment or lightly grease it.
- Pour the potato mixture into the dish and smooth out evenly.
- Bake in the preheated oven for 25 minutes.
Sauté vegetables for the next layer:
- In a large pan, melt butter and add a little vegetable oil.
- Sauté sliced onions over medium heat until translucent.
- Add sliced mushrooms and cook until browned and softened.
- Stir in the grated carrot and cook for another 3–4 minutes.
- Add minced garlic, salt, and pepper. Cook for 1 more minute. Remove from heat.
Slice the baked potato base and layer the filling:
- Once the base is partially baked, remove it from the oven and let cool slightly.
- Cut the base into 6 rectangular pieces but leave them in the dish.
- Spread the sautéed vegetable mixture evenly over each portion.
Add creamy cheese topping:
- In a bowl, mix cream with shredded cheese and mozzarella.
- Spoon the cream-cheese mixture over the vegetable layer.
- Top each piece with a slice of tomato.
- Return to the oven and bake for another 15 minutes at 180°C until golden and bubbly.
Make the herb sauce:
- In a bowl, mix sour cream, mayonnaise, minced garlic, chopped dill, salt, and pepper.
- Stir well and refrigerate until ready to serve.
Serve:
- Once the casserole is out of the oven, let it rest for 5 minutes.
- Serve warm with a generous spoonful of herb sauce over the top or on the side.

Nutritional information (per serving)
Calories: ~320
Protein: 11g
Carbohydrates: 28g
Fat: 18g
Fiber: 3g
Sodium: 400mg

The origins and popularity of the recipe
This layered potato and mushroom casserole draws influence from traditional European peasant dishes—particularly from Eastern Europe, where potatoes, onions, and mushrooms are staple ingredients in both everyday and celebratory cuisine. Over the years, the simple potato bake has evolved with added cheese, cream, and spices for a modern twist. Popular in countries like Poland, Ukraine, and Germany, it now enjoys global recognition as a vegetarian main or a hearty side dish.

Reasons why you’ll love the recipe

Incredibly satisfying and comforting
Budget-friendly and uses staple pantry items

Can be made vegetarian or meat-based with a few swaps
Pairs perfectly with fresh salads or soup
Great for meal prepping or leftovers

Customizable with seasonal vegetables and cheeses

Health benefits

Potatoes are rich in potassium, vitamin C, and fiber.
Mushrooms are low in calories and rich in B vitamins and antioxidants.
Eggs provide high-quality protein.

Garlic and onions support immune function and heart health.
Parsley and dill add flavor while offering anti-inflammatory benefits.

Serving suggestions

Enjoy with a fresh cucumber or tomato salad.
Serve as a vegetarian entrée alongside soup or crusty bread.

Slice into small portions for brunch platters.
Pairs well with roasted meats as a hearty side.
Add a fried egg on top for extra protein at breakfast.

Cooking tips

Let the potatoes drain properly before mixing to avoid soggy texture.
Use pre-shredded cheese for convenience, but freshly grated melts better.
Don’t skip pre-baking the base—this helps it hold up to the creamy topping.
Customize the sauce with lemon zest or yogurt for a tangy version.
For crispier edges, use a metal pan instead of glass or ceramic.

Variations to try

Mediterranean twist: Add olives and sun-dried tomatoes.
Spicy version: Add chili flakes or chopped jalapeños to the base.
Meaty option: Add cooked minced chicken or turkey between the layers.
Vegan version: Use plant-based milk, vegan mayo, and cheese alternatives.
Cheddar mushroom bake: Swap mozzarella for sharp cheddar.

Conclusion
This Cheesy Baked Potato and Mushroom Casserole is one of those dishes that’s just as good on a weeknight as it is for a special gathering. With layers of creamy, seasoned potato, earthy mushrooms, savory cheese, and a fresh herb sauce, it hits all the right notes. Comforting yet light, it’s a reminder that simple ingredients—when prepared thoughtfully—can deliver bold, memorable flavor. Try it once, and it’s sure to become part of your regular rotation.

10 comprehensive FAQ section

Can I use sweet potatoes instead of regular potatoes?
Yes, sweet potatoes work well, but they’ll add a natural sweetness to the dish.
What type of mushrooms is best for this recipe?
White button or cremini mushrooms are ideal, but shiitake adds a richer umami flavor.
Can I make this casserole ahead of time?
Absolutely. Assemble everything and refrigerate up to 24 hours before baking.
Can I freeze leftovers?
Yes, freeze cooled portions in airtight containers for up to 2 months. Reheat in the oven.
Can I skip the cream?
You can substitute with Greek yogurt, milk, or a non-dairy alternative for a lighter version.
Is it possible to make this gluten-free?
Yes, use a gluten-free flour blend in the base and double-check your cheese and sour cream labels.
What’s a good substitute for mayonnaise in the sauce?
Try plain Greek yogurt, vegan mayo, or a mixture of olive oil and lemon juice.
Can I add more veggies?
Definitely. Zucchini, spinach, or bell peppers would all be excellent additions.
Is this dish spicy?
Only mildly, thanks to paprika. You can adjust heat by adding or reducing black pepper or chili powder.
What type of cheese melts best for the topping?
Mozzarella offers stretch, while cheddar or gouda gives a deeper flavor. You can blend multiple types.